Brace yourselves...

[Pride]

Honestly, I think you shouldn't make any arrangement for a prize yet. Guild wars haven't become too competitive yet. As far as I know, there are 2-4 Powerful Guilds out there, such as Memento Mori [led by myself], Manifest [led by @Baaslonn] -etc.

In addition, giving out a prize such a Copper VIP has its own advantages, and disadvantages. In advantages, we have privileges, such as /slap, /tp, /vipprefix [-etc] which are highly desired by most players. On the other hand, giving out a prize like this, could cause distribution problems. Digging a bit deeper, since there is only one Copper VIP as a Prize, only one player will get to keep it. Furthermore, other people might feel left out, as they deserve it too. Lastly, there is also no guarantee that that guild will be the winners of the next war, which contributes to the dissatisfaction of the unhappy members.

If you need a prize to be given, then, in my opinion, it should meet the following condition: The prize should be something that people would strive to win, and all the members of the Guild should have an equal share in it.

Wubwub!

[Panther]

1 vip per week is too much, i suggest making it once per month at most. The guild that wins the most each month will get the vip, and if they tie (4-weeks month), then the leaders (or a chosen vice if the leader is busy) could have one duel to decide the winner. That way, we won't get 1 bronze vip per week on Manifest.

wouldn't that defeat the purpose of the monthly lotto?

Then what panther suggested is even worse, because it's weekly.

But its only 1 Copper VIP, not 3 (Copper, Silver and a Gold)



After Prides comment, perhaps I could make a serious of sub commands that are only available to guild war winners. idk what the commands would be, but that's also something i could do.....

[Enchanted__]

Yeah, VIP is like too much.
What my suggestions are ss, some guild special commands, guild prefix "GW WINNER", an item of choice (as long as its obtainable) and some special stuff

[Brendan D. Winter]

1 vip per week is too much, i suggest making it once per month at most. The guild that wins the most each month will get the vip, and if they tie (4-weeks month), then the leaders (or a chosen vice if the leader is busy) could have one duel to decide the winner. That way, we won't get 1 bronze vip per week on Manifest.

wouldn't that defeat the purpose of the monthly lotto?

Then what panther suggested is even worse, because it's weekly.

But its only 1 Copper VIP, not 3 (Copper, Silver and a Gold)



After Prides comment, perhaps I could make a serious of sub commands that are only available to guild war winners. idk what the commands would be, but that's also something i could do.....

Why not the ones I suggested, then? Or maybe a few of them. That's what I was suggesting, after all >.>

[Pride]

After Prides comment, perhaps I could make a serious of sub commands that are only available to guild war winners. idk what the commands would be, but that's also something i could do.....

I'm glad you understand Panther. About the commands, I'd go with Brendan's post. However, I'd subtract some unfavorable commands from a PvP point of view. In my opinion, you should grant them such commands that will strengthen their offense and will give them the upperhand in the next guild war, just to make things more challenging and favorable for them.

Examples of such commands are /permbuff, /gbuff, /time, /ammo, /handofgod -etc. These commands will become accessible to everyone, till the next guild war. If all of the VIP privileges are given, then the only thing that I'm worried about is command abuse. So, I'd exclude some commands like /slap or giving negative buffs to other players.

I hope this isn't too complicated, and a big hand to Brendan for suggesting this concept in the first place

Wubwub!

[lighty]

maybe Winning Guild wins a chance of VIP for the Leader, and at the end of month, The guild with the most chances (or something like that) wins the VIP.

[Panther]

1 vip per week is too much, i suggest making it once per month at most. The guild that wins the most each month will get the vip, and if they tie (4-weeks month), then the leaders (or a chosen vice if the leader is busy) could have one duel to decide the winner. That way, we won't get 1 bronze vip per week on Manifest.

wouldn't that defeat the purpose of the monthly lotto?

Then what panther suggested is even worse, because it's weekly.

But its only 1 Copper VIP, not 3 (Copper, Silver and a Gold)



After Prides comment, perhaps I could make a serious of sub commands that are only available to guild war winners. idk what the commands would be, but that's also something i could do.....

Why not the ones I suggested, then? Or maybe a few of them. That's what I was suggesting, after all >.>

Well those are vip/normal player commands ( some of them) and i'm thinking more NEW guild spefiic commads that would be managed under the /guild <sub command> kind of format, since controlling how the other commands work would be difficult to manage.

[Pride]

wouldn't that defeat the purpose of the monthly lotto?

Then what panther suggested is even worse, because it's weekly.

But its only 1 Copper VIP, not 3 (Copper, Silver and a Gold)



After Prides comment, perhaps I could make a serious of sub commands that are only available to guild war winners. idk what the commands would be, but that's also something i could do.....

Why not the ones I suggested, then? Or maybe a few of them. That's what I was suggesting, after all >.>

Well those are vip/normal player commands ( some of them) and i'm thinking more NEW guild spefiic commads that would be managed under the /guild <sub command> kind of format, since controlling how the other commands work would be difficult to manage.

New commands? Welp, for that, you might need to look at the suggestion's section. Good luck.

Wubwub!

[Toketsu]

If you want some gw winner only commands, why not add stuff like...

/guild broadcast "message here"   (would act like /vipbroadcast and /say, but would show another name, possibly the guild's name, or just "GW Winner broadcast" if it's hard to code that way.)

/guild advertise   (would automatically broadcast an advertisement message for the guild, can only be used by leaders and vice leaders)

/guild setadvertise "text here" (sets the message for advertisement, can only be used by leaders and vice leaders)

/guild addbuff (guild leaders and vice leaders would be able to put buff ids, like how permbuff works.)

/guild delbuff (deletes added buffs, like permbuff works, leader and vice leader only.)

/guild buff (would activate the buffs for 60 seconds, with a 2-minutes cooldown.)

/guild tp "player name" (would allow /tp between guild members, tpallow blocks it unless used by the leader, preferably having a cooldown)

/guild buy "item name" amount (used instead of /buy while in a shop, to get a 10% discount, has a cooldown of 60 seconds.)

/guild superpoke "player name" (usable by the guild leader only, works like /superpoke, but with double the cooldown time.)

/guild hugall (hugs every online member of the guild, except yourself, preferably with a global cooldown e.g: someone used it, no one else can for the duration of the cooldown, to avoid spam.)

/guild buffall (usable by the guild leader only, would use /guild buff on every online guild member. 10 minutes cooldown, as to not make it overpowered (could combo with /guild buff to get a semi-permanent buff))

/guild checkbuff (would check which buffs have been added to /guild buff)

/guild invasion "invasion type" (would act like /vipinvasion, but without costs. Guild leader only)

/guild (idea coming later)

/guild (idea coming later)

/guild (idea coming later)

/guild (idea coming later)

/guild (idea coming later)

And the ability to build in one of the two large plots in spawn (the ones on the left and right exits, since they aren't in /land as far as i know).

If i think of any others (likely will) i'll edit this post, so make sure to check back.

[Panther]

The ones I like and will probably add are:
/guild broadcast (I think advertise is redundant because its pretty much the same just not on a timer)
/guild tp (let guild members use /tp to people)
/guild buff (buff all onlin guild members)

Permbuff for whole guild might be a bit op, advertise one on a timer would be difficult/spammy, buffall is what buff would do, huggall is more of an emote/fun command, im planning on redoing a lot of commands after 1.3.1, buy would need to tie into the shop plugin which might be a bit messy too :/

I might add /guild summon, which would spawn mob in the Guild Zone, could be fun for mini events or even to help fight guild wars